We loved our wedding here. The weather had been bad all week, but at noon on the Saturday we were married, the sun was shining bright with just a few puffy clouds. You could see Catalina it was so clear. The people at Wayfarers were very helpful. Note that you only have 2 hours (1 hour before the wedding and about 30 minutes after) for pictures on the grounds. I was late before the wedding (arrived just in time to put on my dress and walk down the aisle at noon), so we only have pictures of my husband out on the grounds beforehand, and then the 2 of us together afterward. Make sure you are on time and that all the people traveling with you are on time and ready to really get the most use out of the grounds for pictures.
The minister interviewed us about a week before the wedding. I was worried it would be a very impersonal ceremony, but he worked in a story of how I started dating my husband and it was great. They will also accomodate special readings and the like if you want.
Click on each tool to see a sample.