We loved Nassau Valley.
The only down side is it can get a little pricey.
If you can afford to spend a little more on your Reception site then go or it. Nassau creates a great atmosphere, the staff and owner are very nice and they really care about you as a couple.
Beautiful location, unique setting, rustic feel, and staff were very friendly. Only complaint is that the rental prices seem a little steep for what you're actually getting, which is literally just the space.
Click on each tool to see a sample.