Hello. Congratulations on your engagement! I would highly recommend checking out the Old Stone Church in downtown Cleveland. We had an absolutely wonderful experience with both the wedding coordinator Judy M. and Dr. Giuliano. http://www.oldstonechurch.org/about. If you do happen to talk to them you can mention Marc and Tiffany from London, Ontario.
They are open to all denominations so no worries there. My husband is Catholic and I consider myself Lutheran. Our guests praised the service as it was uplifting and spiritual without being overly religious. I absolutely loved our ceremony : ) The marriage preparation provided as part of the package was worthwhile too. If we lived in Ohio, I would attend the Old Stone Church regularly as I felt so welcomed. (I grew up in Lorain County.)
Click on each tool to see a sample.