We rented our reception chairs from Taylor's Rental. It is misleading when you first see the facility so don't be alarmed! After all Petoskey is a small town so I guess it's not uncommon to rent wedding supplies and tractors from the same location:) We ended up renting gold chivary (spelling?) chairs with ivory cushions. The only reason I gave them three stars is they are a little overpriced but I guess when you monopolize the wedding rental business in the area you can do that. Also, they didn't have a website which was a little inconvenient but it looks like they do have one now.
Click on each tool to see a sample.