Do you have a reception location yet? Or are you looking for a ceremony/ reception site all in one?
You could look at some of the Bed and Breakfast in downtown NA
St. Marks UCC does not require you to be a member. They're on Spring St. in downtown New Albany.
Eastside Christian Church, Jeffersonville, IN
Have you tried The Grand? It's the old movie theater with beautiful chandeliers. They have additional items which they use for the ceremony free of charge (aisle runners, candelabras, etc). You can also personalize a saying free of charge to display on the marque "Happily Ever After Starring ..., Now Presenting ..." etc. The link below is some google images of The Grand.
Click on each tool to see a sample.