How many guests do you think you'll need to seat? St. Bronislava is a popular Catholic church in Plover (you can see some photos here - http://www.lifeisartphoto.com/blog/tag/st-bronislava/). I also really recommend The Woodlands church in Plover (it's non-denominational, the wedding coordinator Marsha is really nice, between Plover and Stevens Point, and you can find some photos here - http://www.lifeisartphoto.com/blog/2009/plover-wedding-photography/) Or if you want an outdoor chapel, there is the Chapel in the Woods at the Red Mill in Waupaca, though it's a half hour from Stevens Point (photos here - http://www.lifeisartphoto.com/blog/2010/red-mill-waupaca-wedding/). Best of luck, I hope the wedding plans go well!
Click on each tool to see a sample.