Are you looking to provide something for your guests or just have a place to all go together?
We had an "after the rehearsal dinner party" at The Corner Alley. It is a martini bar bowling alley on E. 4th street. I know you can rent the back room with 4 bowling lanes and a private bar (you can have it as a cash bar if you don't want to pay for alcohol) for $350/hour. Bowling lanes in the main area are $50/hour.
Really anywhere on E. 4th street would be fun... Wonder Bar, Zocalo (Mexican themed). Or there is a new place on prospect called RJ Bolands. They have some private rooms with separate bars and prices are soooo reasonable. I've been to a few parties there already.
anywhere on west 6th is great....lots of fun places
Click on each tool to see a sample.