Have you checked Old World Wisconsin? They have a cute roundish barn that I think can seat about 100-130, maybe? And I believe they'll let you pick your own caterer and everything... We looked there, but decided against it because it's not very close to hotel accommodations and we had about 75 people coming from out of town. Good luck!
I was going to say the same thing about Old World: http://oldworldwisconsin.wisconsinhistory.org/Visit/Restaurant.aspx
it's not a barn, but for a nice outdoorsy wedding reception you might want to check out the Audubon
My name is Catharine Han and a wedding planner in Milwaukee. I know of a few places in and around the milwaukee area. Please feel free to contact me at email@example.com.
That was my first thought too! I really wanted a country theme wedding but on a budget but I can't seem to find anything around the milwaukee area either. I found a barn in the grafton area but it was too far and the guy didn't seem like he wanted our business (he gave us 3 minutes to see the place) good luck!
what did you end up doing?
Click on each tool to see a sample.