1. Catering by Leslie (http://www.cateringbyleslie.com/) is affordable and the food is good. It is a much smaller company so the prices reflect that.
2. New York Food Company (http://www.newyorkfood.com/) this will cost more but their food and service is amazing. This is a large company so it costs a bit more, but there is a level or professionalism that you get when you use a large company.
Hello! we can be of service(http://www.afairytalewedding.com). If you look at our menu, we offer selections you've mentioned above. Our price is unbeatable and our service and professionalism as well. We deliver, set it up, tend it, to make sure your buffet is kept full and warm the time you're serving it, we pick up and we tear down! We also include linens, china, and silverware with the meal. Visit our website to see samples of our menus and give us a call for a complimentary consultation.
I'm a budget bride and we're working with Critic's Choice (http://www.criticschoicecatering.com) right now. They're pretty flexible - just be thorough and let them know what you want.
Click on each tool to see a sample.