I am not sure if Hastings is outside your search radius, but I highly recommend Green Mill in Hastings. I used them for my rehearsal dinner and reception catering. Tim O'Brien is the manager and he is fantastic - ask for him when/if you call. Besides the food, the other bonus is that Tim and his crew will set you up in a more formal and intimate rehearsal dinner location next door on the third floor of the bank building (elevator accessible). We did a pizza/salad/wings/dessert buffet with an open bar.
Green Mill/Tim O'Brien 651-438-9160
Thanks Liz... I think we are trying to stick closer to River Falls but I appreciate your suggestion! :)
Click on each tool to see a sample.